Retirement Plans

Financial security and independence are central to retirement planning, and in order to achieve these goals, some important factors need to be taken into consideration and they are summarized below.
The work life expectancy (WLE)Generally 30-40 years; shorter if already in workforce
The retirement life expectancy (RLE)The time period between retirement and death
Savings concepts, incl. investments and inflationSavings rate, timing, investment decisions, and inflation
The retirement goal definition (Retirement needs)Analysis on pre-tax and post-tax basis
The work replacement ratio (WRR)Estimate of retirement income need
Sources of retirement incomeSocial security, private pension/retirement, personal savings, and full-time/part-time work
Qualitative factors*Involuntary vs voluntary retirement, emotional and psychological factors, relocation, etc.

*Though qualitative factors appear last on the list, they are as important as or in some cases more important than quantitative factors.

Types of retirement Plans

Broadly speaking, there are three types of retirement plans – qualified plans, nonqualified plans, and tax-advantaged plans. Some, but not all-inclusive, common plans available in the workplace today are described below.

Qualified PlansNonqualified PlansTax-Advantaged Plans
Defined Benefit (DB) Pension PlansDefined Contribution (DC) Plans  
Traditional DB pension planSection 401(k) planSection 457 planSection 403(b) plan, incl. Roth
 Roth 401(k) planTraditional IRAs
   Roth IRA
What is a qualified (retirement) plan?

It is an employer-sponsored retirement plan satisfying the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section 401(a) requirements for receiving tax-deferred treatment (i.e., tax benefits).

What is a nonqualified (retirement) plan?

It is any retirement plan not satisfying the Internal Revenue Code (IRC) section 401(a) requirements for receiving tax-deferred treatment (i.e., tax benefits).

Qualified Plans

Traditional DB pension plan

  • A pension plan that provides a specific benefit at retirement
  • The objective is to maximize plan contributions for the benefits of older employees/owners
  • The employer bears investment risks.

Section 401(k) plan

  • A retirement plan with before-tax elective deferral contributions
  • An individual account with accumulated benefit at retirement or termination
  • The employee bears investment risks.

Roth 401(k) plan

  • A section 401(k) plan with after-tax elective deferral contributions
  • The main difference between Section 401(k) plan and Roth 401(k) plan is the tax treatment of contributions and distributions.
Nonqualified Plans

Section 457 plan

  • A deferred compensation plan of governmental units, governmental agencies, and non-church-controlled, tax-exempt organizations
Tax-Advantaged Plans

Section 403(b) plan

  • A tax deferral employee plan for certain tax-exempt organizations and certain public schools and colleges (i.e., the not-for-profit industry)
  • Though not a qualified plan, it offers many of the same benefits and complies with many of the same rules applicable to Section 401(k) plans.
  • Some plans may offer Roth 403(b) plan option.

Traditional IRAs

  • A tax-advantaged personal savings plan where contributions may be tax deductible

Roth IRA

  • A tax-advantaged personal savings plan where contributions are not deductible but qualified distributions may be tax free